GA

SUPER READERS
Title:  The Wish List
Author:  Eoin Colfer
Reviewed by: 

Reviewer: Joe K. '12

This book is about a girl named Meg who has a hard life and ends up being a criminal with a partner named Belch. They try to rob an old man. Their dog bites the man when he comes down the stairs with a shot gun. He lets go of the shot gun. Belch grabs it and they run away.

Then Belch shoots a gas tank because he wants to die and escape time in prison. Meg and Belch die. Belch goes to Hell but Meg is too good for Hell and too bad for Heaven. She must help the old man, Lowrie, complete his three wishes on his wish list, to go to Heaven.

I think that this would appeal to people who like ghost stories because it has a lot of ghosts.

The author, Eion Colfer, has written the Artemis Fowl series. If you like those books because the hero isn't perfectly good you would like this too.

Fall 2004

Reviewer:  Gordon F. '11

The Wish List is a great book about a girl who is sent down to earth after she dies to help a person whom she has wronged. In order to go to heaven she must complete a list of wishes that the person wrote. Completing this list is not as easy as she thinks it will be and she meets many challenges along the way.
 
This book has a good lesson that I think everyone needs to learn and try to live by. You should help everyone no matter who they are.

Spring  2004

Reviewer:  Hirsh S. '11

This book was about a young criminal named Meg who dies in a robbery. To decide if she will go to heaven or hell, she has to have more good or bad deeds, yet Meg has exactly the same number of good and bad deeds. She is sent back to earth by God to complete good deeds so she can go to heaven. But the demon from hell wants her to come down with him, so he sends saboteurs to prevent her from doing good deeds. They are a computer, and Belch, Meg's partner in crime who went to hell. Meg has to help old man Lowrie complete his wish list so he can live in peace for the last six months of his life, and Meg can go to heaven. Do they finish the wish list? Read this great book to find out! 

Spring 2004

Book Reviews For Kids - By Kids


5th Grade Super Readers Team
Betty Grant - Lower School Reading Specialist
Andrea Owens - Home Page Coordinator, Editor
Kathy Wyzsomierski
- Reading Teacher, Editor
Bridget Flynn - Lower School Librarian

Germantown Academy

Last updated 11/17/2004

Super Readers | Lower SchoolGAnet