GA

SUPER READERS

cooney1.gif (5760 bytes)

Author Index

Title Index

Super Readers
Title:  The Face on the Milk Carton
Series: The Janie Quartet
Author:  C. B. Cooney

Reviewed by : 

Reviewer: Nia H. '13 

Janie Johnson has a normal life until she sees her picture on the milk carton at school.  Janie and her boyfriend, Reeve, try to figure out why she is on the milk carton.  Do they find out why?  Read this excellent book to figure out if they do or if they don't.  I would recommend this book to boys and girls  who like mysteries.  

Fall 2005

Reviewer: Kellie B. '12

This is a book that is filled with emotion, drama, surprises, and suspense. Janie is finding out about her past, while living in the present. The missing girl on the milk carton- well, Janie thinks that it is she. All of a sudden, she can't think or sleep, and memories of when she was little start to come back to her. Part way through the book you begin to imagine what is going to happen, but then the author throws in more twists and turns to keep you guessing and imaging the outcome.

Fall 2004

 
Reviewer:  Ali P. '11

The Face on the Milk Carton is a awesome book. It has a lot of suspense. It is about this girl named Janie who sees herself on a milk carton. It looks just like her when she was a little girl. She looks for clues to find out what happened.

Winter 2004

Reviewer:  Stefanie L. '10

Spring 2003

Reviewer:  Rebecca O. '10

One day a teenage girl, Janie Johnson, takes a sip from her friend's milk carton even though she is lactose intolerant.  Janie looks down at the carton and sees a familiar person on the back of it.  That familiar person has been kidnapped!   When she looks closer at the person, she recognizes it as herself!  Could she be kidnapped?  If so, who are her real parents? Read the book to find out.

Spring 2003

Reviewer:  Jackie G. '10

The Face on the Milk Carton is about Janie, a girl who eats the same lunch everyday - a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and a small carton of milk.  Janie always looks at the back of the carton to see the picture of the missing child. One day when Janie flips the carton over she sees a picture of herself as a little girl. Janie goes to her mom and asks to see her birth certificate. Her mom asks why Janie wants to see it. Janie makes up a little white lie, but her mom still does not show her the certificate.

To find out who that girl is on the back of the milk carton, read this book. I recommend it to people who like mysteries and suspense.

Spring 2003

Reviewer: Stephanie S. '10

Janie is just an ordinary girl when one day, she just happens to look on the back of her friend's milk carton at school. Suddenly, Janie gets a weird feeling in her stomach. The little girl on the back of the milk carton was three years old, and had been kidnapped twelve years ago in a shopping mall in New Jersey. Then it hits her. She remembers the polka dotted dress in the picture. She remembers those tight pigtails. That little girl is her!

Janie doesn’t know how she ever could have been kidnapped. She has two wonderful parents who would do anything to keep her safe. Janie starts a little research and things only get more and more complicated. Who is Janie really?

Winter 2002/2003
Reviewer: Elizabeth W. '10

This story is called The Face on the Milk Carton.   It is about a girl named Janie who sees a face on a milk carton and thinks she has been kidnapped, because the face on the milk carton looks just like her as a little girl.   She investigates this matter to find out and while she is looking she meets a boy who she falls in love with.  

Read this book and find out if she was really kidnapped, and if her parents aren't really her parents, and who that boy is that she's in love with!

Next in the series:  Whatever Happened to Janie

Fall 2002

Reviewer:  Alissa F. '10

Janie, a 14 year old girl, looks at the missing child on her friend's milk carton and realizes that it is her! In he rattic she finds a dress that says "Hannah" on it. In the chest is the same polka -dotteddress  that is on the milk carton!  She finds all these other things out about when she was little and weird things. Have her loving and caring parents kidknapped her? Read the book to find out!!

Fall 2002

Reviewer:   Katie C. ’08

One day a girl named Janie sees her picture on a milk carton. She wonders if her parents are her real parents, or if she has different parents. She tells her friends, but they don’t believe her. Janie goes through lots of things in their attic to see if she is related to her family. She sees a box with a girl’s name on it, but she doesn’t know who the girl is. Janie asks her parents whose trunk she found in the attic. Her parents say that it belonged to their daughter and that they are her grandparents. But Janie knows that she must have another family.

I like this book, and I would recommend it to people who like romance and mystery.

Spring 2001

Reviewer:   Lauren L. ’08

Janie Johnson was living a normal life until she saw the picture on the milk carton. The person on the carton was Jamie. How could this be? Her parents never told her about this. Mr. And Mrs. Johnson aren’t the kidnapping type. Are they really Janie’s parents? If not, what really happened to Janie? Who is she?

Fall 2000

Reviewer:  Josh K. '07

The main characters in The Face on the Milk Carton were Janie Johnston, Janie’s parents and Reeve. 

One morning Janie was eating lunch, looked on a milk carton and found out that she was kidnapped. How could Janie live through her life when she was kidnapped and never notice? That was Janie’s question. Janie keeps getting more and more confused as more strange events take place during the story. How will this book turn out? You’ll have to read it to find out. 

I thought that this was an excellent book because the chapters were all very suspenseful, and that made it hard to stop reading. I thought this was a superior book, and if you want to see if you like it as much as I did, then you should read The Face on the Milk Carton

1/31/99

Reviewer:  Ben S. '07

It was the red hair, two ponytails, and that awfully itchy collar of that turtle neck, all there on the side of the milk carton that said, "Missing." That locked box in the attic, the locked drawer in the desk, the missing birth certificate, the shopping mall in New Jersey, these are only some of the things mixed up in Janie Johnson’s life. As memories started to come back more questions arose. Did she give up her family for an ice cream cone? Are her parents kidnappers? Does she have a second life? Read The Face on the Milk Carton to unwind the twisted tale of Janie Johnson, or is it Javensen?

1/21/99

Reviewer:  Abbe H. '07

Janie Johnson is a Massachusetts teenager who drank milk from a carton and found a picture of a kidnapped child displayed on it. Later Janie gets flash-backs of her childhood which leads her to believe she was kidnapped. Janie starts an investigation by going to New Jersey where the child was kidnapped, searching her parent’s attic, and asking questions of everyone. Was Janie actually kidnapped or is it just her imagination? 

10-27-98

Reviewer:  Karin B. '06

The Face On The Milk Carton was about a girl, Janie, and a boy, Reed. Janie was sitting in lunch one day and decided to look at the lost little kid on side of the milk carton. When she looked, she recognized the person. It was she. It couldn’t be, she thought. I have loving parents and a happy life. Still she couldn’t help but keep the milk carton. Later that week, she and Reed drove to New Jersey to find the family and they did. 

I liked The Face On The Milk Carton because it kept me wondering what would happen next, and it was hard to put the book down. I recommend this book to anyone who likes books with mystery and a little romance. 

6/8/99

Book Reviews For Kids - By Kids

Title Index  |  Author Index | About Super Readers


5th Grade Super Readers Team
Betty Grant - Lower School Reading Specialist
Andrea Owens - Home Page Coordinator, Editor
Carolyn Purdy - Reading Teacher, Editor
Bridget Flynn - Lower School Librarian
 

Germantown Academy
Fort Washington, PA

ganet2.jpg (2017 bytes)

Last updated June 2006

Super Readers | Lower SchoolGAnet

ganet2.jpg (2017 bytes)